Drukarnia.BLOG

MLB The Show 26 All-Time Teams EXTREME U4GM Guide

The All-Time Teams EXTREME Program in MLB The Show 26 takes you through a long series of matchups against historic lineups, starting with individual clubs and ending with the best players from across the league. You can earn 160 Program Points across 39 missions, so there is plenty to play for as you work through the schedule. If you are also planning upgrades with MLB Stubs, take a close look at your lineup before the longer games arrive.

How the Program Works

The program is split into eight groups. The first six cover the five individual teams in each division, with every matchup played over three innings. Each of those missions awards 4 Program Points, giving you 20 points per division and 120 points across all six groups.

The next group features six divisional All-Time Teams in six-inning games, worth 25 points in total. The last group, The Final Gauntlet, contains three nine-inning games worth 15 points altogether. Each mission displays "Get 1 stat," while the group descriptions tell you to defeat the opposing team. Plan around winning each game to earn progress.

AL East and NL East Missions

The AL East group sends you up against the All-Time Orioles, Red Sox, Yankees, Rays, and Blue Jays. Each victory is worth 4 points, and finishing all five earns 20 points.

In the NL East group, your opponents are the All-Time Braves, Marlins, Mets, Phillies, and Nationals. The format is the same: five three-inning games, with 4 points available from each mission.

Three innings leave little time to recover from a slow start. Put hitters you trust near the top of your order, since they are most likely to receive multiple plate appearances. A single early run can change how comfortably you approach the rest of the game.

AL Central and NL Central Missions

The AL Central slate includes the All-Time White Sox, Guardians, Tigers, Royals, and Twins. Complete the five missions for another 20 Program Points.

For the NL Central, face the All-Time Cubs, Reds, Brewers, Pirates, and Cardinals. Each matchup again awards 4 points, for 20 points across the group.

Pitching decisions matter even in these short games. If your starter gets into trouble, consider making a change before the inning gets away from you. Keep an eye on the next hitters in the order and choose a reliever you feel comfortable using against them.

AL West and NL West Missions

The AL West missions feature the All-Time Astros, Angels, Athletics, Mariners, and Rangers. Beat each team to collect the full 20 points for the group.

The NL West group includes the All-Time Diamondbacks, Rockies, Dodgers, Padres, and Giants. These five games also award 4 points apiece, bringing the division total to 20.

By the time you finish these groups, you will have completed 30 individual team missions. There is no need to rush through them in a single session. Playing a division at a time makes the schedule easier to track and gives you a natural stopping point.

Divisional All-Time Teams

After the individual club matchups, the divisional group brings together one All-Time Team from each division. These six-inning games give you more room to settle in, but they also demand more from your pitching staff.

AL East All-Time Team: 4 points
NL East All-Time Team: 5 points
AL Central All-Time Team: 4 points
NL Central All-Time Team: 4 points
AL West All-Time Team: 4 points
NL West All-Time Team: 4 points

The NL East matchup is the only game in this group worth 5 points. For all six, think ahead about who can cover the middle innings and who you want available if the score stays close. At the plate, be patient enough to wait for pitches you can hit well.

The Final Gauntlet

The last three missions are full nine-inning games against the American League All-Time Team, the National League All-Time Team, and the MLB All-Time Team. Each win awards 5 points, for a total of 15.

These games require a different rhythm from the opening missions. A quiet first inning does not decide the outcome, so avoid pressing at the plate. Use your bench when a substitution gives you a useful matchup, and keep watching your pitchers as the game develops.

Before starting the final stretch, review your roster and make sure you have reliable options throughout the lineup and bullpen. Players who choose to buy MLB The Show Stubs can use them to consider upgrades that fit their approach, while the most important preparation is knowing which players you trust when a close game reaches the late innings.

Articles about local business and interesting people:

Share your ideas in a new publication.
We are waiting for your longread!
Galina Autokemp

Galina Autokemp

@aQx_CCi7tLcmRLY

79Longreads
1.6KViews
On Drukarnia since December 3 2025

More from the author

You may also be interested in:

Comments (0)

Support the author first.
Write a comment!

You may also be interested in: