Drukarnia.BLOG

They Ignored the Warning. Then They Looked. Then They Did Nothing.

Institutions facing a risk they would prefer to ignore fail in two steps, two authors in La Paz, Bolivia, argue in an essay: they avoid looking, and then they look without acting.

The World Meteorological Organization's headquarters in Geneva, June 2021 (illustrative). Photo: malavoda / Flickr, CC BY-NC-ND 2.0

José A. Ríos and Jimena Sainz posted their 29-page essay to the Zenodo repository on Oct. 10, 2026. It deals with how institutions handle knowledge and risk, and its central line is about attention. An institution confronted with an unwelcome risk, they write, moves through two stages: "first, avoiding looking; then, looking without acting."

That is the whole essay in one sentence, and it is difficult to argue with.

The wider frame

Their thesis is that climate governance, built over three decades around cutting greenhouse gas emissions, needs a wider frame. The authors argue that the Earth has to be governed as one system, in which atmosphere, oceans, ice, life and human societies interact. Seen that way, a climate question becomes a risk question: which hazards could cascade, where the vulnerabilities sit, what capacity exists to respond.

"If climate change is understood as a systemic phenomenon," they write, "governance itself becomes part of the risk architecture."

They would keep the Paris Agreement, the UN climate convention and the IPCC in their current functions. What they find missing is a body with a mandate to assess, together, the risks that arise from climate change, environmental degradation, institutional fragility and conflict. In their reading, no institution currently holds one.

Two habits

Their premise concerns how organizations learn. "Systems do not learn simply because they receive more information," they write; "they learn when they can modify the assumptions through which that information acquires meaning."

Two habits get in the way. The first, which they call the ostrich bias, avoids a warning before it can be read. The second, denial bias, accepts the evidence in the abstract and keeps it disconnected from anything anyone does.

The main remedy

Their main proposal is what they call epistemic traceability. Each decision would come with a record of the scientific conclusion that informed it, the evidence that supports that conclusion, the uncertainties it carries, the alternative hypotheses that were considered and the point where the available knowledge runs out.

Bias can enter scientific advice without anyone manipulating evidence, the authors write, through the selection of research questions, indicators, models, time scales, information sources or evaluation criteria. A traceable record would put those choices where someone outside the room could see them.

Which, put plainly, means: when a decision about a planetary risk has been made, can anyone say what the evidence for it was?

The other two ideas

The second idea comes from medicine. Primary prevention was set out in a 1965 public health textbook by H. R. Leavell and E. G. Clark, and it means acting on the causes and structural conditions of a risk before it materializes. The authors carry the principle over to planetary risk themselves. In their version, emissions cuts stay, and they sit inside a broader architecture alongside adaptation, resilience and preparedness.

The third idea gives artificial intelligence a defined place. The authors would use it to keep maps of the evidence current between formal assessment rounds. They write that AI could strengthen institutions such as the IPCC "without replacing them, functioning as supporting scientific infrastructure" and that it should not settle which hypotheses are true or which risks a society should accept. It can also reproduce whatever bias sits in its data or its training. Technology alone does not transform governance, they conclude; it needs cultural leadership, and the essay's centerpiece is a concept they call Systemic Cultural Leadership.

The caveats, stated by the authors themselves

The authors describe their framework as an "analytical matrix to guide future research agendas," and its central concept as "a proposition." The two-level relationship they propose is, in their own words, "a conceptual hypothesis that may be developed and subjected to empirical testing in future research."

So: an essay, not a study. A framework, not a finding. A proposition, not a result. The authors are unusually explicit about this, which is more than can be said for most people who write about governance.

The backdrop

The physical backdrop comes from the World Meteorological Organization. On May 28, 2026, it published its annual to decadal update and put the odds this way: "It is very likely (91% chance) that the global mean near-surface temperature will temporarily exceed 1.5°C above the 1850-1900 average levels for at least one year between 2026 and 2030."

The WMO attaches its own caution: individual years above the level "do not mean that the long-term temperature goals of the Paris Agreement are out of reach," because those goals refer to warming sustained over roughly 20 years.

The 31st UN climate conference is meeting in Antalya, Türkiye, from Nov. 9 to Nov. 20, 2026, according to the United Nations. The essay predates it and does not mention the conference.

Ríos is the ALLATRA Global Research Center's representative for Latin America and the Caribbean; ALLATRA also publishes this site. That is a disclosure the reader can do something with, which is more than most governance essays offer.

Sources
  1. Tracing the Evidence Behind Climate Decisions, an Essay Proposes

Articles about local business and interesting people:

Share your ideas in a new publication.
We are waiting for your longread!
bigviktory

bigviktory

@bfH04QSpwutJ8MZ

11Longreads
164Views
On Drukarnia since October 4

More from the author

You may also be interested in:

Comments (0)

Support the author first.
Write a comment!

You may also be interested in: